Choosing what is meant to be
By Rod Van Mechelen
"How do you know when it's love? I can't tell you but it lasts forever." Van Halen, OU812
What price, passivity?
1996 Bellevue, Wash. - "If it is meant to be," the Cosmopolitan horoscope for 1996 reads. As
Warren Farrell noted in Why Men Are the Way They Are, these are
words that figure prominently in the holy writ of modern femininity.
"If it is meant to be," he'll find a way. "If it is meant to be," you'll just happen to
bump into one another atop the Empire State Building one fine May afternoon. "If
it is meant to be," everything in your lives will conspire to bring you together. "If
it is meant to be."
Like the old Doris Day song about "whatever will be, will be."
Speaking of a love lost to her long ago, Yetta sighed and told me, "If it was meant
to be, it would have been."
"Just because something is meant to be," I replied, "does not mean it
will be." We are, after all, free to choose.
Remember the story of the religious man caught by a flood. Warning came: the
river will flood, flee while you can. "If it is meant to be," he replied "God will
save me." The flood came. Stranded, he sat on the roof of his house waiting for
God to save him. A boat came. "Leave me" he said, "if it is meant to be, God will
save me." A helicopter came. "Don't fret for me," he called out, "if it is meant to
be, God will rescue me." After he drowned, he approached God and asked, "Lord,
why did you let me drown? Why didn't you save me?" To which God replied, "I
sent you a warning, then a boat, then a helicopter. What were you expecting, a
legion of angels?"
That's the thing about being human: we are free to choose. Tricky thing, free
will. Taking responsibility is part of the package. We can choose to do what
is meant to be and not to do what we shouldn't, not do what is meant to be and do
what we shouldn't, or take no responsibility at all, leave everything up to chance,
and sigh "whatever will be, will be."
Feminists like Catharine MacKinnon complain about this. She says women are
that way because men want them to be that way so they'll be passive, easy to push
around, rape, get them to do the dishes. Yet even in Marilyn French's recent book,
The War Against Women, we find passing references to how most men,
even in the most patriarchal societies, prefer women who are not passive.
Well, okay, so that was in reference to sex, not to the larger context of life in the
big city. Here in the states, however, according to a recent survey on traditional
versus equal partnership marriage relationships, American men reported that they
are much happier in fifty-fifty relationships. That they do prefer
relationships with women who are full partners. So, whatever was true
about men wanting women to be passive, it's no longer true. At least not in
America.
Ironically, in the same survey women reported being less satisfied in such
relationships. Taking responsibility has a price. But, as Betty Friedan noted in her
landmark book, The Feminine Mystique, the rewards of being an adult --
full participation in life -- far outweigh the cost.
Jill was excited about a man she just met. He was gorgeous and fun. They flirted
and exchanged phone numbers, and now she was waiting for him to make the next
move. "Will he call?" she fretted. All day long, she worried about it. Finally, she
took the initiative, called him, made a date, and they were both glad she did.
More and more, men expect women to meet them half way. We have to, because
we know that if we misread a woman's cues or signals, we can be accused of
sexual harassment, stalking, or, in extreme cases, even date rape. As a friend at
IBM once told me, "I never make the second move."
What that means for women is that the more passive they are, they are less likely
to have relationships with sensitive, intelligent men, and more likely to fall prey to
domineering men who are prone to violence.
In this cultural climate, then, the price of passivity for women is to be a victim, see
another woman get the relationship meant for her, or worse.
If it is meant to be, it is up to each one of us to see to it that it happens. The best
way to do that is not to sit around waiting for a legion of angels to let us know, a
magical moment to make everything clear, or Cosmo horoscopes, but to
get into the habit of making ethical choices. Get into the habit of doing right, and
what is meant to be, will be.
Regards
Rod Van Mechelen
Rod Van Mechelen is the author of What Everyone Should Know about Feminist Issues: The Male-Positive Perspective (the page now includes several articles by other authors), and the publisher of The Backlash! @ Backlash.com. He is a member of the Cowlitz Indian Tribe and served for 9-1/2 years on the Cowlitz Indian Tribal Council.